Sign up for a free trial and your first month is $1. Sign up now
Sign up for a free trial and your first month is $1. Sign up now
When shoppers land on your store, the journey doesn’t always begin on a product page—it often starts on a category page. These pages act as gateways, helping customers browse multiple items at once and decide where to click next.
Traditionally, reviews have lived on product pages, where shoppers dive deeper before making a purchase. But more brands are now experimenting with showcasing ratings and feedback directly on category pages. Is this a smart move?
In this article, we’ll break down the pros, cons, best practices, and real examples to help you decide if this strategy fits your store.
Category pages are often underestimated. Many merchants treat them like simple product directories—just thumbnails, prices, and filters. But in reality, category pages play a huge role in guiding shoppers toward purchase decisions.
If these pages don’t inspire trust or excitement, shoppers may leave before ever reaching your detailed product pages. That’s where the idea of adding reviews comes in.
Let’s start with the positives. Done right, showing reviews on collection pages can be a powerful trust signal.
When shoppers see star ratings directly under product thumbnails, it creates immediate confidence. They don’t need to click through to know whether a product is popular and well-received.
Example: Amazon does this brilliantly. Every category page shows average star ratings and review counts. It’s one of the reasons Amazon converts so well—customers can trust the product before even clicking.
Online shoppers are often impatient. Displaying reviews helps them eliminate poor-fit products quickly and focus on those with strong feedback. This speeds up the browsing process and reduces “choice paralysis.”
Products with visible 4.5 or 5-star ratings tend to attract more clicks. This can help highlight bestsellers and guide shoppers toward higher-converting items.
By placing reviews on category pages, you’re inserting social proof earlier in the journey. Instead of waiting until the product page, you’re building trust at the browsing stage.
Some review plugins allow rich snippets to appear in Google search results for category pages. This can lead to higher CTR from search engines because your listings look more attractive with stars.
Of course, it’s not all upside. Adding reviews to category pages comes with challenges that store owners should carefully weigh.
Category pages already pack in a lot—images, prices, titles, filters. Adding star ratings and review snippets can make the layout feel crowded, especially on mobile devices. Poorly designed review displays can overwhelm rather than reassure.
Imagine browsing a category page where the first few products show 3-star averages. Instead of inspiring trust, it may discourage the shopper entirely. Unlike product pages (where negative reviews are balanced with context), category pages show blunt ratings without nuance.
Pulling review data for multiple products at once can slow down category page performance. On Shopify and WooCommerce, page speed is critical—if reviews cause lag, it may hurt conversion more than help.
If review content is duplicated across multiple product and category pages, it can confuse search engines. While rich snippets help, overuse of review data can sometimes backfire for SEO.
In certain niches (luxury goods, high-end fashion, B2B products), reviews might cheapen the browsing experience. Shoppers in these markets may value exclusivity and curated presentation more than peer validation.
If you decide to experiment with reviews on category pages, you need to implement them strategically to maximize benefits while minimizing drawbacks.
Show only the essentials: average star rating + review count. Avoid long review snippets that clutter the page.
Consider displaying reviews only for bestsellers or products above a certain rating threshold. This ensures first impressions stay positive.
Design with small screens in mind. Ratings should be compact and not push down important elements like product images or “Add to Cart” buttons.
To avoid slowdowns, load review data efficiently. Many Shopify and WooCommerce review apps (including Ryviu) offer performance-optimized widgets.
Run an A/B test: one version of your category page with reviews, one without. Track CTR, bounce rates, and conversions to see if reviews make a measurable difference.
Amazon is the poster child for reviews on category pages. Every product shows star ratings and counts. It works because:
A Shopify clothing brand tested adding reviews to category pages. Result:
A WooCommerce store selling gadgets added review badges to category pages.
These examples highlight a key lesson: the impact varies depending on your store type, product range, and execution.
As eCommerce evolves, we’ll likely see more advanced ways of integrating reviews into category browsing:
Adding reviews to category pages isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. Done thoughtfully, it can create instant trust, highlight bestsellers, and guide shoppers toward the right products without extra clicks. But done poorly, it risks clutter, slower load times, and even negative first impressions.
The key is balance: design a clean layout, showcase positive ratings strategically, and test whether the change boosts conversions for your audience. Remember, social proof works best when it enhances—not overwhelms—the browsing experience. By carefully weighing the pros and cons, you can decide if reviews on category pages are a conversion booster or a distraction.
