Sign up for a free trial and your first 3 months is $1/month. Sign up now
Please select the platform to install
Please select the platform to login

How to Redirect Users After 404 Pages to Capture Conversions?

Technology
Dec 12, 2025
9M
Alice Pham

A 404 error page is usually seen as a dead end, the moment when a user reaches a page that no longer exists, has been moved, or was typed incorrectly. While most store owners treat 404s as unfortunate but inevitable, strategic brands see them as hidden opportunities. When handled thoughtfully, a 404 page can be a turning point that guides users back into your sales funnel rather than letting them abandon the site.

Redirecting users from 404 pages is one of the simplest yet most effective ways to recover lost traffic, preserve SEO value, and convert otherwise frustrated visitors into engaged shoppers. Instead of letting the journey stop at a broken URL, you can redirect users to a meaningful page that matches their intent, or even introduce them to products, promotions, or new arrivals they may have missed.

To help you leverage this often-overlooked tactic, this guide explores why 404 redirects matter, how to set them up, and the best strategies to maximize their conversion potential.

Why Redirects from 404 Pages Matter for Conversions?

A 404 page is more than just a message saying “page not found.” It signals a moment of interruption in the user journey. This interruption often causes:

  • Frustration
  • Confusion
  • Loss of trust
  • Abandonment

When users encounter an unexpected error, they tend to leave immediately, especially if they’re on mobile. But when you provide a smart and relevant redirect, you instantly recover their browsing flow and lead them to a page with purpose.

Redirects Improve User Experience

By guiding users back to a functional part of your site, you remove friction and keep them engaged. Even when they land on a dead link, the transition feels intentional rather than disruptive.

Redirects Protect SEO Value

Old or deleted pages often carry valuable backlinks, ranking positions, or internal links. Redirects preserve link equity so that all SEO power flows to your new page rather than being wasted.

Redirects Reduce Bounce Rate

A user who would have left within seconds is now directed to a page with useful content or product options. This keeps users on your site longer, signaling higher quality to search engines.

Redirects Increase the Chance of Conversion

Many users who land on a 404 originally intended to take action, view a product, explore a category, or learn about an offer. Redirecting them to a similar or upgraded alternative keeps their intent alive.

With these benefits in mind, redirects become more than a technical fix, they become a crucial conversion strategy.

Where to Redirect 404 Traffic to?

To maximize conversions, the redirect destination must match user intent as closely as possible. Below are the most effective options, along with detailed reasoning behind each one.

1. Redirect to a Similar Product Page

If the original URL belonged to a product that is discontinued, sold out, or renamed, redirecting visitors to a similar product helps maintain the shopping momentum. This is especially effective in niches like fashion, electronics, or home décor, where customers often look for alternatives or different variations.

Why this works:
When customers land on a 404 for a product, they’re usually already motivated and in “buying mode.” If you redirect them to a comparable product, they’re far more likely to continue browsing rather than giving up. This redirect feels natural, almost as if the product evolved rather than disappeared.

But if you cannot find an equivalent product or the URL is no longer directly tied to one item, broader pages may work even better.

2. Redirect to a Category or Collection Page

If the broken URL originally belonged to a broader niche or category, leading users back to the parent collection gives them a larger set of options to explore. For example:

  • A broken “/women-dresses-blue” URL can redirect to “/women-dresses”
  • A discontinued gadget can redirect to the entire tech accessories collection

Why this works:
Instead of showing one product, you give users a curated set of alternatives. This improves their chances of finding something else they like while keeping the browsing experience smooth.

However, when you’re unsure what the user was seeking, a more general destination may be more appropriate.

3. Redirect to the Homepage

While not always the most targeted, the homepage is a reliable fallback. It serves as the central navigation point, making it easy for users to choose their next steps, whether that’s searching for products, reading content, or exploring promotions.

Why this works:
Homepage redirects are helpful when the broken link is unrelated to products, comes from external sources, or carries unclear intent. They provide a neutral but effective way to keep visitors engaged.

But if you want to maximize conversions, not just retain users, you may want to take a more proactive and promotional approach.

4. Redirect to a Promotion, Lead Magnet, or Special Offer

One of the most underrated strategies is turning a 404 moment into a conversion moment. You can redirect visitors to:

  • Flash sale pages
  • Limited-time discount pages
  • New arrival collections
  • Clearance deals
  • A page offering a discount code in exchange for an email

Why this works:
Instead of seeing an error, users see an exclusive opportunity. This not only reduces frustration but also transforms the experience into something rewarding.

Still, some users prefer navigating independently, which makes the next option ideal for user-led exploration.

5. Redirect to a Search Results Page

If the broken URL contains keywords (e.g., “/black-running-shoes”), you can automatically run a site search and redirect users to the results page.

Why this works:
Users feel as if the site understood what they were looking for and provided options instantly. This reduces effort and increases the chance of finding a relevant match.

How to Set Up 404 Redirects: Step-by-Step Guide

While the concept is simple, effective implementation is what ensures smooth user experience and SEO consistency.

1. Identify All Broken URLs

Before you can redirect anything, you need to know which URLs are causing problems. Use tools like:

  • Google Search Console → Coverage → Not Found (404)
  • Screaming Frog → Crawl errors
  • Platform-specific 404 tracking (Shopify, WooCommerce, etc.)
  • Plugins like Redirection, Rank Math, or Yoast

Why this step matters:
A single broken link may seem harmless, but collectively they can drain traffic and hurt SEO. Identifying them lets you take control.

Once you know what needs fixing, the next step is choosing the right redirect type.

2. Choose the Correct Redirect Type

There are two main redirect options:

  • 301 redirects (permanent)
    Ideal when content has been removed or replaced long-term. This passes SEO equity to the new page.
  • 302 redirects (temporary)
    Useful if a page is being updated and will return soon.

After selecting the redirect type, your next task is mapping each broken URL to the appropriate destination for maximum relevance.

3. Map Broken URLs to New, Relevant Pages

The goal is to match the original intent as closely as possible. For example:

  • Old product → Updated or similar product
  • Old category → Parent category
  • Old blog post → Updated blog post
  • Unknown URLs → Homepage or search page

Why relevance matters:
Misleading redirects create confusion, increase bounce rates, and can harm your SEO trust signals.

With your mapping in place, you’re ready to implement the redirects on your platform.

4. Implement Redirects Using Your Platform Tools

Different platforms offer different methods:

  • Shopify:
    Online Store → Navigation → URL Redirects
  • WooCommerce/WordPress:
    Plugins such as Redirection, Rank Math, or Yoast SEO
  • Magento:
    Marketing → SEO & Search → URL Rewrites
  • Custom websites:
    Edit .htaccess (Apache) or Nginx rules

Once everything is set up, it’s crucial not to assume your work is done, redirects must be verified.

5. Test, Monitor, and Adjust Over Time

Testing ensures:

  • The redirect activates instantly
  • The target page is correct
  • The user experience feels smooth
  • No redirect chains or loops occur

Monitor your redirects monthly, especially if you regularly update products or restructure content.

Best Practices to Maximize Conversions from Redirects

Redirects work best when guided by both user behavior and SEO principles. The following practices ensure every redirect contributes positively to your site’s performance.

1. Always Prioritize Relevance

Relevance directly affects whether the user continues browsing or leaves immediately. A user who wanted “blue silk dress” should not land on the general homepage or a blog post. Matching intent increases trust and keeps engagement high.

2. Avoid Redirect Chains

A redirect chain happens when URL A goes to B, which goes to C. This slows down loading time and weakens the user experience. Whenever possible, redirect old URLs directly to their final destination.

3. Pair Redirects with a Helpful Custom 404 Page

Even with redirects, some URLs will always slip through. A custom 404 page acts as your safety net. Add:

  • A search bar
  • Links to top collections
  • A small discount or coupon
  • Clear navigation buttons
  • A link to new arrivals or bestsellers

This ensures that even unredirected errors can still lead to conversions.

4. Keep a Central Redirect Map

As your store grows, you may create dozens or even hundreds of redirects. Documenting them helps prevent duplicates, loops, or conflicts. It also helps you audit them periodically.

5. Use Analytics to Optimize Future Redirects

Check data such as:

  • How often each broken URL is triggered
  • Where users go after being redirected
  • Conversion rate changes after redirects
  • Bounce rates of redirected traffic

This data gives you insights into user intent and helps refine your mapping strategy.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Creating 404 Redirects

Even well-intentioned redirects can backfire if not executed carefully. Avoid these pitfalls:

  • Redirecting all 404s to the homepage, this confuses users and frustrates Google.
  • Using temporary redirects for permanent changes.
  • Allowing redirect loops or chains.
  • Redirecting to irrelevant or thin pages.
  • Forgetting to test after each implementation.
  • Redirecting to pages that don’t match the original intent.

The goal is not simply to get rid of the 404, it’s to guide users toward value.

Conclusion

Redirecting users after they encounter a 404 page is a powerful yet often underused strategy. Instead of losing potential customers at the very moment their journey is disrupted, you can turn that dead end into a new beginning, guiding them toward relevant products, categories, promotions, or search results.

When implemented thoughtfully, these redirects preserve SEO value, boost engagement, reduce bounce rate, and directly increase conversions. The key lies in understanding user intent, choosing the right redirect destination, and ensuring smooth, transparent navigation.

404 pages don’t have to be conversion killers. With a strategic redirect approach, they can become the bridge that leads users toward the next purchase.